Skip to content

November 19, 2026 · 4 minute read

How to judge AI assisted work: a short guide for managers

It has never been easier to produce a document that looks finished. That is useful, and it creates a new job for every manager: telling strong work from work that only looks strong.

Why this is suddenly a skill

In a 2025 survey of 1,150 full time US desk workers, 40% said they had received "workslop" in the last month. The researchers define it as AI generated content that looks good but lacks substance. People estimated about two hours to deal with each instance.

Looking right and being right can come apart. In an experiment with 758 consultants, AI improved speed and quality on tasks that suited it. On a task chosen to sit outside what the model of the time did well, consultants using AI were 19 percentage points less likely to produce a correct solution.

And trusting the tool seems to go with checking less. In a survey of 319 knowledge workers, higher confidence in generative AI was associated with less critical thinking, while higher confidence in their own skill was associated with more.

Five habits for reviewing AI assisted work

None of these need technical knowledge. They need a clear idea of what good looks like, and the willingness to say so.

  • Say what good looks like before the work starts. A clear brief is the cheapest quality check there is.
  • Check the facts that matter. Pick the two or three claims the whole thing rests on and trace them to a source.
  • Ask the author to explain it. If they cannot say why it is right in their own words, it is not ready.
  • Give feedback on the thinking, not the polish. Ask what they would cut, and what they are least sure of.
  • Make it normal to say "AI helped with this, and here is what I checked." People hide what they fear will be judged.

It is a standard, not a suspicion

None of this means distrusting your team or the tools. It means holding the same standard you always held, now that drafts are cheap. The manager’s job moves from producing the work to knowing what good looks like, and saying so.

Sources

  1. AI-Generated "Workslop" Is Destroying Productivity (opens in a new tab). BetterUp Labs and Stanford Social Media Lab, in Harvard Business Review, 2025.
  2. Navigating the Jagged Technological Frontier (opens in a new tab). Dell’Acqua and colleagues, Harvard Business School working paper, 2023.
  3. The Impact of Generative AI on Critical Thinking (opens in a new tab). Lee and colleagues, Microsoft Research and Carnegie Mellon University, 2025.

Curious what REEDS could look like for your team? Let's talk.

Book an intro call
Dave Collins

A 30 minute call with Dave Collinsof Oak & Reeds Interactive Training

Not ready to book yet?

Leave a note and Dave will reply to you himself.

How to judge AI assisted work: a short guide for managers | Oak & Reeds